Funniest Pod Ever!!

Trust the title!

I work way to much and never got into the podcast thing but a friend suggested your Crime in Sports. I am sooo addicted to you guys! I started from show #1 and just finished Willy Mayes Aiken, so I have a ways to go. I am so glad I work out at 3:30am because people would think I am a absolute laughing nut job. Thank you for doing this and I will hopefully see your comedy routines someday, I have found my people, finally! Only podcast I listen to (until I get into Small Town Murders!).

These two are the best, great with information as well as being hilarious. Keep the episodes coming

Look I don’t even like sports but jimmy and James could read the federal tax code and make it entertaining. True comedy gold which has made me laugh too hard in inappropriate settings.

I have been a long-time listener of Small Town Murder, the duo’s other long-running podcast. I held off listening to this one simply because I was swamped with podcasts. But when I got caught up in a bunch, and some went away, I figured it was time to start this one. It is fascinating to listen to the early episodes, as this podcast started before Small Town Murder. It gives me so much more insight into the growth of both this particular podcast as well as the personal growth of Jimmie and James. Can hardly wait to find a live show of theirs I can attend so that I can finally meet them! I’m a major fan!💜

Hilarious, You should do one on Adrian Peterson

I have your clean towel

Week after week after week.

Throw those turtles in the garbage!!

Greatest story tellers of our time.

Love the Jimmies.

Great show

I’m just here for the panhandle behavior

I love all their podcasts!

This show is brought to you by the letter J

I believe most people like James and Jimmie must realize they are popular or funny, but they are so much more than that. From the depths of my heart, I can say these two incredible individuals have not only kept me engaged but have brought laughter into my life during times when I had little else to smile about. For years, they've given me something to eagerly anticipate, providing a beacon of joy when other lights had dimmed. In my darkest hours, knowing I could tune into them was a comfort, a predictable source of happiness in an unpredictable world. No matter how challenging life became, unwinding with James and Jimmie was my solace. Beyond their exceptional humor and undeniable talent, their relatability is what truly sets them apart. If I ever have the opportunity to attend a live show, I would like to convey this to them in person. I suspect they might not fully grasp the profound impact they have on their listeners' lives. Their influence goes far beyond entertainment; it's a lifeline for many, including myself. Thank you so much. Rachel 💙

Love these guys and all their podcasts! I dont think theres been more than 2 days this year i haven't listened to one podcast of theirs or another. Great job perservering James & Jimmy! You're both incredibly entertaining!

Their worldview seems like that of ignorant boomer white men. I couldn’t get though the Jayson Williams episode which was the first episode I ever listened to. Sure the guy did some bad stuff but they were very dismissive and judgmental regarding what seemed like a challenging upbringing. I’m all for some roasting but their jokes were mean spirited and not nearly as funny as they seemed to think

Whistman isn’t funny he just says yeah a lot and laughs at inopportune times. Petragallo is so good it makes up for it though. Highly recommend

Just give it a listen, would ya!

Keep it up! Love you guys I’m so glad you’re keeping Crime in Sports!!!!

Started listening to Small town murder back in 2022 when a coworker suggested it… but James and Jimmie are hilariously amazing and keep suggesting this so I figured I’d give Crime in Sports a shot. I’m not a big sports fan at all! You don’t need to be!! You learn so much from them explaining things and learning names along with dates and it all correlates with other episodes. It’s so funny I make everyone listen to it who likes podcasts. Love these guys!! 10000/10 stars ⭐️

Like they say, you don’t have to like sports to enjoy this podcast. They both crack me up! I listen to all three of their podcasts and they are all great

They just keep getting funnier. They have saved me from loneliness when my mother passed away. ❣️❣️

I love y’all even more for James’ appreciation and adoration for Hunter Thompson. Talk about the coolest dude, ever

What a story.. thank you.

As a Small Town Murder junkie, finally listened to their advice after being told at least a thousand times and what do you know…they weren’t wrong. I care -1890% about sports, but love the show and have learned a few things along the way. You just need to like their humor, they make ANYTHING funny. Love you guys!

I find you guys through your Stupid opinions podcast which I found just searching around for new podcasts to listen to. I didn’t realize there were so many criminal athletes and how funny both of you are telling the stories of these lunatics. I can’t wait to get to your other podcast murders in small towns. Keep up the great work love you guys.

Love you guys!!! We were at your show in MN💕 So great!

I have been listening to you guys since episode 10 I love it so much it’s my weekly routine soon as midnight hits tue I check in on the newest episode. Love the reboot on Hurricane you really did that justice taking another look at it. Hope I get a shout out your fellow James Cooke Ps I’m a disabled US army veteran shout out to all my fellow vets you listen to y’all

I discovered Jimmy and James with small town murder and have listened to all of their shows now. Every episode of all of them are hilarious

They adopt arthritic goats!

I am not into sports what so ever but I love true crime and comedy and James and Jimmie make this Podcast the best of both worlds

Can’t get enough of James and Jimmy!!

Awesome show! Equal to small town murder

Someone suggested Small Town Murder to me because they actually covered a killing in a town where I grew up. They plug a Crime in Sports a lot so I thought I’d give it a listen. I’m a causal sport guy at most but these two are great comics and great storytellers that will make anything sound great. After a few episodes o actually just started from the beginning and honestly here’s the think I love the most… zero political or social comments. It’s about the topic at hand and you’ll never be bombarded by their politics or social views. It’s beautiful and refreshing. Thanks, keep it up

Great podcast!!

It’s ok to laugh at these idiots because they had it all and blew it. schadenfreude at it’s finest! Also metatarsals are in your feet Jimmie!

By far my favorite podcast duo. These guys are hilarious and work together so well. It is obvious they truly enjoy what they do.

Love you guys. The best.

I wanna see earth wind and fryer 😂😂😂😂

I’m late to the party… I started out listening to Small Town Murder a few years ago. After I listened to every single episode, I decided to do the same for Crime in Sports. Let me say I don’t don’t like sports and I don’t care about much of it, but the stupidity of the choices that land these athletes on a podcast is highly entertaining. If you aren’t listening, why? You don’t have to like sports. Aaannnddd, I am so happy the show isn’t cancelled and I like the shorter episodes as well. XOXOXO to J & J, all the researchers, and producers who keep it going!

These guys are hilarious.

I love sports and I love true crime so I love it, but if you don’t like sports it’s still hilarious, you guys are so funny and do such a great job getting all of your details. I listen to Small Town Murder and Your Stupid Opinions too, love them all! I had tickets (small town murder) last time you were in Philly but couldn’t go last minute 😫 I will make the next one 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

I listen to a lot of shows as I drive 2 hours a day because of work. There’s something about these two. The skill they have in keeping the attention of the listener even keeps me fully into it after a 12h night shift. A+

I’m continuing to follow your show it does make my day to hear the unfortunate truth and news about past sports stars known and unknown. I’m following instructions!

Small town murder fan who came over to crime in sports. Absolutely don’t need to like sports, as they always say! Love it!!

Best podcast around. Found out my friend listens and got excited to finally talk about this show. Then I realized he only listened to the famous episodes. He’s not my friend anymore. I’m listening to Scottie pippen now. I’ll be up to date in a bout a year and a half!

I’m not really into sports, but this podcast is one of my favorites! James and Jimmie are hilarious together, and I actually find the stories so interesting!