Bad acting, subpar storytelling, and an overabundance of f-bombs (like listening to a middle schooler learning to swear).

Too short wish it had lasted longer

The voice actors are good at reading, but quite bad at acting. None of them portrays a character, they are just reading words from a script while giving absolutely no life to the words.

Can’t remember if I started with the White Vault or with Liberty first. Liberty is by far my favorite and I have written a few fan fictions based on Liberty. The world of Atrius is very fleshed out and it’s neo-marxist society is very believable. The thing I don’t like about Fool and Scholar is, for some reason, they felt the need to go back into all off the old episodes and inject their pro-abortion views by placing fund raising ads for their pro-abortion friends. Disgusting!

Sci-fi and religion collide in well written and voiced stories. Highly recommended!

When you starts featuring garbage from other stuff not worth the subscription or listening to this junk.

100/100

I was very intrigued by the story, and I wish I could have stuck it out for more than three episodes. The voice actors are so dry, deadpan, and inexperienced it made it impossible to continue to listen. Absolutely completely unbelievable in their roles. interesting story, boring storytelling.

I started on the white vault podcast and it was amazing to find more by fool and scholar is wonderful, love the vast horizon, white vault, critical research, all of them are great

I’m loving it so far. The character Boom reminds me a lot of Ed from cowboy bebop.

It was vet disappointing to see Critical research end. It was a vey good story and there wasn’t even a good ending.

Almost done with Episode 7…. … Ok, Yup, I’m in!!!!! Thank youuuu!!!!! This is amazing!

The story only goes up to season 2. The rest of the seasons are PG rated garbage short horror stories. Horror is not their genre if you’re looking for horror , magnus archives, darkest night , down etc are all good. And then they randomly hop into table top games. The first 2 ATRIUS seasons regarding the fringe are fantastic. But that’s all you get is 2 seasons that relate to the actual story. what a letdown.

Up until the part where there was no ending. How did y’all write such a good story and then just leave so many questions unanswered? There seemed to be a building point where we were about to learn what the driving forces for the story actually wanted, then poof, nothing. I still listen to the other stories but none of them really seem like they need to be set in this world, aside from a few changed words here or there.

As is everything produced from Fool and Scholar this is a show that is evident in the time and work invested in it. The voice work, the sound editing, and the writing are all top notch. Put that together and you have a supremely enjoyable and digestible art form. I never expected to be invested in this world, having come from white vault and vast horizon, but Liberty and the strangely enticing world that it paints is just as good.

It’s ok. The voice acting is here and there but season 5 was awful. It sounded like a laborious run on sentence. Also, the language l/“slang” used was….weird: caffeine in place of coffee, meal in place of food. Overall, it was an ok listen.

Vigilance has been my favorite thing you guys have done! I love dark dice but man Vigilance was so great! Thank you for all the work you out in I love all of your work!

It was a cool show for the first 4 seasons. Season 5 is unlistenable. The actors are sooo bad. It’s almost as if they don’t know how to read. I’d give season 5 one star for the three episodes I suffered through. I’m skipping to season 6. It has to be better

I LOVE THIS PODCAST! Omg, Tales from the tower are one of my favorite things to listen to during my day to day. They really draw you in with all the layers in each episode. I highly recommend this podcast as well as other works by fool and scholar productions. You will not be disappointed.

Totally love what you guys are producing Keep it pumping ATREUS ENDURES

So good

A blazingly original and unique concept for a podcast. The voice talent is exceptional and the audio quality is exquisite. Brilliantly done. Needless to say, would love more!!

I just finished White Vault and needed more. I’ve been pretty pleasantly immersed while I pack to move, but the brothel episode left a bad taste in my mouth. Bracing for these characters I’d grown to like to say something alienating really ruined the storytelling for me. Bummer. I hope the writers have learned better since then.

This is the first podcast of this kind I have ever listened to, and with that being said I can say I won’t look any further! But now I’ve listened to all episodes of the game in two days I need more 😍 those are my absolute favorite with the story and all the decisions that were made and all the characters that showed up and not to mention the unscripted bursts of laughter and fun I enjoyed of second of listening and can only hope for more! Please keep up the amazing work!

This is one of the best shows I have ever listened to especially during these trying times where entertainment has become an essential part of society. I had a question that is not relevant to be put here ,but I was not able to find a fool and Scholar productions e-mail or address to send this question to: Do you consider taking volunteers or unpaid interns to help with work ?

I’m a bit late to the game but still a great podcast. I love the world you made!! Would be a great dnd world! I found out that you had made it a dnd world lol and have bought it. I finished all the podcasts made for this show in almost 2-3 weeks. I listen to them at work but I absolutely love this show. And I can’t wait to run a liberty campaign. I’m thinking of doing a war campaign. Possibly the red war now from the sounds of the tower episodes.

The world you’ve created is really captivating, the political dynamic of the Atrius and the fringe and listening to the team learn about the unknowns of the fringe is awesome. Keep up the amazing work.

Hard to engage when every actor sounds like they are reading lines.

I am always looking for a new story...this one is fantastic. Love the character development... the story, the music, um ok. I love it all. Great job guys! Thank you

Just finished with the first season of the first story, and I LOVE it! I listen to it as I wind down for the night, and when I need something to listen to during the day, and I can't wait to get to the next season. The worldbuilding is awesome!

I love what you are doing here. I just wish there were more episodes of each story! I just start really getting into a story then it’s done. :(. Ps. I live the voice of the narrator in this story. I also like the main character voice, sounds like Octavio from king of the hill

Whoever does the character of dismous is hilarious

I love it y’all need to continue the story

I’m just amazed at how amazing the world they build is! I heard it’s also a comic and a tabletop! I gotta check that out one of these days! I even enjoyed them playing the dnd style table top in vigilance! Woot woot can’t wait for what’s up next!!

Currently listening to Vigilance and who’d have thought listening to an rpg would be such giggling fun!

The world is great, the writing is amazing. Definitely a podcast worth listening to. Unique world and I love each episode. Thrilling drama!!

The episodes are too short. Like 10 min or so. Then you have to listen to the info again. They should just combine them into 30-40 mins so you don’t have to keep listening to the dumb intro.

Great story, which matters the most, but it feels like some voice actors are reading off the script for the first time. This makes it less believable or less engulfing. I was never in theater, but I’m pretty sure memorized lines come out more naturally. I’m comparing this to the no sleep podcast, lime town, and the black tapes. Either way, I’m hooked till the end and it’s a great listen/mental visual spectacle. I’m going to binge the 2nd season after homework.

This is the best among the Fool and Scholar Production catalogue. I realize that humanity likes to gravitate towards a realistic setting like in The White Vault. Yet, this whole world of Atrius is so much bigger and attractive to me. I keep listning to the Liberty podcast whenever I can. I think Kaitlin & Travis(both Creators) are rockstars and they have only explored the Fringes(bad pun intended) of the Liberty universe. May the Archon watch over them.. They too nice to go boom.. Oh! umm..I mean..Atrius endures...

Creepy, futuristic, almost believable... prepare to spend a lot of time with Fool & Scholar

Binged the first season

I like White Vault better but one thing I find especially frustrating about the Liberty universe is that the writing (especially the dialogue) feels forced, awkward, and inconsistent. Boom and Dizzy are without question the best characters in Liberty - they’re very well-acted roles. Otherwise, kind of mediocre.

Need more of the fringe please

This is exactly what I needed to pass time at work. Such good stories and well edited!

I love the sci fi seasons, and while it took me a while to get into Tales from the Tower, I’m starting to enjoy them too, albeit not as much.

This show is very entertaining. I especially get lost during the critical research series. I wish they had more of that series. The other series are entertaining for a short story, but I don’t feel any connection with the character or characters like I do with the critical research characters. Can’t wait for them to start with the rest of that series hopefully it’s coming soon. It reminds me so much of mad max. I’ve been waiting for a drama series like that and I can’t find anything any closer then this series. Great job love your work.

Great storytelling, interesting take on the future. I am hooked!!!

The best produced roleplaying podcast I’ve experienced

Came here from The White Vault (One of the best audio dramas I’ve ever listened to!) and Vast Horizon. Both impeccable and engaging stories. Unfortunately, I can’t seem to get through Liberty. Excessive throat clearing, repetitive soundscapes, and seemingly limited editing make for an experience that is almost engaging, but falls short.

Just recently found this podcast via the White Vault via The Magnus Archives. Excepting the first season of Critical Research, this podcast has been quite excellent. The first season the writers and producers were still finding their sea legs, so its quality is less than everything after. Personally, my favorite stories are Tales from the Tower. Then again, I’m a sucker for a good anthology series a’la Ray Bradbury Presents. Keep up the good work!!