Patrick, I finally heard what was the significance of the Western Empire falling. It was falling. It was changing. Every time I read of heard of the Western Empire falling I thought: “Here is the end of the Roman Empire”. As you so eloquently said it, it was only one of the Empires which fell, i.e. the Western part. Your imagined scenario with imagined characters clarified what had happened. Thank you for that.

Thanks for the great pods on the Punic Wars, Patrick. The pods with Bret Devereaux were pure gold.

If you enjoy the free episodes you will enjoy these. Wondery+ did not have lineup I wanted to subscribe to annually;but there is a monthly version which I’ll use to listen to ToH. Great listening.

Too many commercials

Great interviews, excellent narratives, real historical knowledge.

This is a must for anyone who enjoys history. A true immersive podcast that brings to life and battles. I love this show!

Heard about this pod through Trash Future. I’ve been studying the German Peasants’ War for the past year so this is a gold mine of a find. Great production, excellent topics!

Excellent. I really appreciate the historical criticism/historiography Patrick Wyman regularly slips in to his narrative.

The episode with Dr. Gino Campari was fascinating. Like Patrick, I can’t wait to hear more about “The Spectral Cavalcade.”

Been looking for a prehistory podcast that gives review of existing science but also uses narrative and I couldn’t be happier that I finally found it. Series from 2020 is rocking my whole world. I suddenly feel like I did when I was a kid discovering all these things about science on my own and in school. Life is exciting again! So good.

Ohhh nooo I’m a character Patrick is talking about at the beginning of an episode. Oh dear I live in changing times and a land of contrasts, but I also have a sense of strong precedents. Oh man what if I’m living in an era where historical forces collide oh nooo Patrick starts the episode with a little vignette illustrating something going on in the life of an average Joe, and that’s not an accident at all. He has a deep respect for what it was like to live through the dramatic moments covered, which benefits the pod greatly. Highly recommended!

Love the show, just one request. Please stop the drinking and gulping at the beginning when characters are drinking, it’s like nails on a chalkboard. I have to skip ahead. It’s right in my ears with my earbuds. Again love the podcast 😊

Please stop the slurping, drinking and also the annoying background music.

I really love listening to Patrick Wyman and his fascinating topics because they are so well researched and his depth of knowledge! I recently listened to Other Ancient Civilizations with Raven DaSilva. I have been needing out by watching videos in YT about the Hok pottery and the Plastered Skulls!

Excellent

Accessible history - presented in understandable narrative form that tells the story, or several versions of the event with color commentary on the odds of the several versions. The stories are woven together so that connections become evident. Amazing use of visuals. And tells the stories using characters to illustrate the story. And brings in recent fact sets such as climate change with associated pandemics, famines, population declines, and deterioration of economic, civic, religious, educational, and cultural roles of the cities, without which the cities of the west sputtered and returned to its unconnected state.

Used to be a great podcast but the content has become increasingly pro-Islamist and ahistorical when it comes to the ancient levant. Refers to Cananites as Palestinians in a blatant political bias.

I’ve been listening to Tides for a couple years, and listened to Patrick’s Rome pod before. I don’t know how I’ve never left a review before! I love his presentation and casual manner, and the depth of research done into the periods and topics.

I wanted to get into this podcast but apparently they made the brilliant decision to make all the early episodes “wondery+” access only. I’m not sure if they’re trying to alienate new listeners or just don’t care because it makes no sense at all.

I love the pod. Well spoken, interesting and informative. That being said, “Alexander liked to fight, full stop.” That threw me. Way skidbidi. Cruegy. You lookin like an op on that Ohio toilet rizz. Be sigma. Betas pander. You are better than that sir. This comment is placed in jest, cap.

Pre-history series is awesome beyond words! Keep up the good work 👍

Please make it easier to navigate the feed on Apple. Dividing into series or seasons would be extra helpful. Thank you for all you do!

So good my brother and dad listen to this and now I do because it helps me fall asleep Patrick is such a good narrorator and I love the sound affects

Dear Mindy Thomas, you’ve been accepted into the CCC (crazy crazy community) your first meeting is on 30/2/25. Emila and Gemma (co-founders)

The narrative history episodes are great: interesting, well researched and written, and well produced with a solid narrator. The guests are good too (though the discussion episodes do leave a lot to be desired from the host’s interviewing skills.) If it weren’t for Wondery constantly pushing inane ads for their other shows in to the feed, this would be a five star review.

I love history and history podcasts when they are done well. Like, Dan Carlin good. Patrick Wyman NAILS IT. Example: Interviews can be iffy or weird. Lot’s of interviewers can’t prop up a researcher who isn’t great on their feet, and when things go flat, struggle to save the moment; not Patrick. He’s right there to spot them and help the specialist get back on track. Done better than a standard journalist. Kuddos, as well, to an excellent audio editing team. In addition to being a pro interviewer, he is not detached. Despite not necessarily having expertise in a topic, he cultivates a subject, and prepares to be an enthusiastic and interested contributor to the conversation. The interviewed people love talking to him. It’s like he has a relationship with them, and they’re having a beer on the patio and chatting deeply and meaningfully about a research topic. He has significant academic credit, but that’s a jump point, not a lane. If he tackles a subject, buckle up. It’s going to be good. The only episodes I’m not crazy about are the occasional book minipods. There. That’s my only meh critique (and that’s just my preference. He does those well too). Not Feckless. Totally OG. If I had to pay beyond my Amazon sub I would. HE’S THAT GOOD.

I say yes. Patrick is a great host who really has a difficult job. He’s gotta make us relate to human being and civilizations thousands of years old, many before writing existed. Yet somehow he does it in such an enjoyable way. He really makes you see the similarities between all humans over the millennia, while not losing what is unique to each culture place and time. Can’t recommend this show enough. Wondery better renew it!!

Love the approach to story telling and truly appreciate how the rationale is shared for the stories presented. Absolute favorite podcast. Hope it continues for a long time to come!

I came to this podcast for the breathtaking array of eras and cultures he covers, from ancient China to medieval Europe. I stayed for the methods! As a non- historian I love learning about the archeological and historical research methods to create the evidence. It’s a window into fascinating professions.

This show is awesome, particularly in covering pre and early history. Patrick is very careful to distinguish what we know from what we speculate happened and the many ways to look at the evidence, including what appears most likely to describe an age and culture.

We love to see it

I always learn a great deal from episodes of “Tides of History”. Patrick’s research and interviews have filled in a lot of gaps in my own education and helped me gain huge appreciation for what has come before. Highly recommend following this series and paying attention to the excellent interviews Patrick frequently includes! Thank you for all the hard work, Patrick!

You will never hear someone sound more full of themselves than Patrick Wynan. An arrogant, smug, egotistical, conceited mansplainer if there ever was one.

The host is smug, condescending, and clearly an egomaniac. He has many episodes where he interviews himself. He literally has other people come onto his show and interview him, on his own show. He actually devoted an entire episode to giving a negative review to a random book that had nothing whatsoever to do with the the time period his show was covering (his co-host is prompted to continually agree with him despite admittedly not reading the book herself). He opens each episode with a really inept attempt at creative writing, for which he always sounds way too pleased with himself (he basically just sees how many adverbs he can fit into a sentence). I wanted to like this show, as it does have interesting material and information which is not well covered in other podcasts. But the awful host makes it really frustrating and difficult to get through a full episode. (Also, the show is all but ruined by loud, repetitive, extremely distracting background music)

This is my favorite podcast hands down and I listen across genres. I replay episodes multiple times and I have new questions and ideas each time, which is a joy.

I get so much out of listening to these podcasts - they are well researched, so engaging (spanning a wide variety of eras and cultures, including, the Austronesian expansion in the Pacific islands, the War of the Roses, ancient African history, and other intriguing subjects). The host and his guests also discuss the process of unearthing historic discoveries.

Love the story of the Scythians. I know most people don’t ride horses. I am a long distance trail rider. I ride with my legs. It’s easier than you think, and preferred. Having said that, it’s all about that trust relationship with the horse. They are really great beings!

Deeply researched and thoughtful. Shows a lot about process and the contingent nature of our knowledge. Great story telling too.

This is a wonderful podcast. As a United States History teacher I have been able to gather so much knowledge for this podcast. The in-depth information that has been presented allows me To be a better educator.

It grabs and holds enough of my interest to want to stay awake and the delivery + sound effects make it like I’m drifting off to some mythical land in sleep. It keeps my mind from racing as I start to drift and the longer it grabs my attention, the better I sleep. I tend to skip guest interview episodes for episodes downloaded for sleep time. The ancient history content is on repeat but it’s all high quality content.

Amazing episodes that get me excited about history.

I am delighted I found a podcaster who is willing to start with the Denisovans and chronicle every step to the present. It is stunning the amount of scholarly study and inclusion of so many fields to arrive at an opinion. This is a masterclass! Jim T

I have found this podcast to be informative and presented well. However, it does seem to be written with an obvious tilt to a liberal view of history. Wish it was more objective and less biased.

Must listen

This was the first podcast I tried years ago, and it’s still my favorite. I’ve enjoyed every season. Patrick explains things in such a clear, well-thought-out way. He brings up things that I’m still thinking about days later. He does a great job of reminding us what we can and can’t find out from archeologists, ancient historians, literature, and DNA evidence. I never feel like he’s dumbing down the material for us. The sound effects and music are top notch , and the stories he creates about the imagined everyday lives of “regular” people from the past are very effective. I tend to prefer the episodes that are just Patrick over the interviews, but those are good, too. This is the one podcast that I’m nearly always caught up on! Thanks to Patrick and his crew for all the hard work you put into it. I hope you’ll continue for many years to come!

I’ve been listening to this podcast from the beginning. I found a lot of other history podcasts that would only provide a summarized and superficial view of historical events, but this one finds the right balance between telling a good story and providing detailed and insightful analysis of each topic. Always looking forward to the next episode!

Amazing binge-worthy show. Literally the only reason to subscribe to Wondery, but it still makes it worth it.

This is my new favorite podcast. Always been interested in history but there is a lot I thought I knew but Patrick has filled in so much more and helped me understand the context. It feels like a good story —-never a dry history lecture. Easy to follow. Highly recommend.

What’s up, Wondery? This show is the only reason I subscribe to Wondery. It’s great. But your feed has been atrocious. Please fix it.

The only history podcast I know with great historical fiction snippets that makes it come to life for me. Very well researched, balanced and concisely written episodes. Among the podcasts I regularly listen to, this really is one of the highlights of the week for me!