Discovered Josh Ritter on Killer Psyche so I searched for other podcasts by him. I love his insights & ability to clearly explain cases.

DNA Now! ❤️ Michigan loves you!

I’m a big fan of Josh, found him on Killer Psyche. I just happened to find this and I love it!

Thank you for trying to bring justice to families.We have suffered for 21 years.

I’m new to the show. I don’t normally watch or listen to crime shows but somethings gotten into me this last year and I’ve been really into it. Anyway, this show happens to be so good that I’m listening to vintage episodes.

Love this show. But Josh needs to stop breathing into the mic 😑 it’s distracting when a guest is talking.

I tried to listen a few times but the cackle at the most inappropriate things and times is truly so weird. On the Panini case, not once did she say oh this woman committed a crime. Nope, instead she made fun of the appearance of the ex-boyfriend. And I never knew how irritating the phrase “Don’t you find it interesting” could become.

I started listening to this podcast back in January, i was instantly hooked. The detail pout into each episode is phenomenal. Unfortunately, i find the random advertisements in the middle of each podcast annoying, not to mention that the host and any guests he may have drag on each case a little too long. I don’t mind if they go into further detail, but they sometimes go over things not related to the case. Overall; however, i say it’s a great podcast. 👍

The lawyer on this show was so sanctimonious. Has he not heard how hard it is to get mental help for anyone when you are poor? He says nothing about the underlying issues as to what is wrong with our young people. I love this show, but this one makes me want to quit listening.

I look forward to each new episode! Thank you! MK

The fact that the guy was on Joe Rogan’s podcast tells you everything you need to know about the guy 😂 Not a single person should be surprised that he’s a murderer

Love the topics, but the host really doesn’t know how to host. Garcia doesn’t let her guests get a word in edgewise.

Love how Joshua Ritter covers the cases with or without a cohost this is a must listen for getting my true crime fix! Fantastic perspective on these timely and relevant cases!

I like this podcast. I consume a lot of true crime podcasts so this is a nice reprieve from some of the other things I listen to. Ana is my favorite host. It’s like I’m listening to friends chat about true crime topics. I was surprised to read some poor reviews - people need to lighten up and stop trying to make this podcast into something else… I think it’s great as is. ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️

These episodes are like ABC gum. Reporting on old chewed up stories that have no relevance or substance anymore. Rehashing highly publicized cases of yesteryear that no one has any interest in. Snooze. Pass. Unsubscribe.

A lot of simplistic discussion and lamenting of evil from Ana Garcia and her admiring guests. “Sidebar” with Josh Ritter, however, contains more intelligent discussion, and I find it worth the listen..

This is one of my favorite podcasts. Always interesting!

I have a love/hate relationship with this podcast. I want to like it so much, but Anna Garcia is so over the top and so extra. Laughing when people die or just her faux outrage in other “analysis”. She makes it seem like SHE is the victim at times. I love the guest hosts though!!!!!! And I love the Sidebar episodes. I only listen to the Friday episodes when I can tolerate it.

I have to disagree with ur take on the Alex murdaugh jury verdict! First off evidence was more then just the video although Paul put Alex at the scene! It was also his trucks onstar motion that tract him showed him slow down exactly where Maggie’s phone was thrown as well as his cell phone data showing over 200 steps after the murders! Also the prosecutor brought up the motive as “the family annihilator” theory the definition Alex clearly shares the traits of this typed of person! I do agree the prosecutor did take Alex’s financial misdeeds personally because Alex practically destroyed the judicial system down there giving question to all practicing lawyers! Also he was giving closure to these victims! Other then this I love listing to ur podcast as well as ur guests

The host needs to go she’s too much, I’ve turned many episodes off midway because she’s just awful and over talks the people who actually know what’s going on

I just listened to the one about Dale Holloway. Two women are on. One of them (the host?) doesn’t know her elbow from a gavel, and the other one isn’t much better. They spent35 minutes talking about the case without hardly mentioning one fact about the case. I didn’t know who the “Bishop” was until they finally divulged it. They laugh and blunder their way through, until I just couldn’t stand it any more. ONE STAR

Is to find out how to pronounce a key person’s name. Like that is the literal LEAST you could do. This show is amateur city.

I tried listening to a couple of these but could never make it through a complete episode. Ana is the worst host ever. She fumbles around and often cannot finish a thought. Very cringe’

I’m with Will about the McDonald’s fries! LOL Love the show. Very entertaining. I highly recommend listening especially if you’re interested in criminal law.

This podcast is turning extremely “Fox News-ish” use to be a huge fan, not so much anymore. I do plan on continuing to listen but it’s becoming distasteful and I would not be suprised if I deleted this one soon. The hostess picks and chooses what crimes sgainst women she has strong feeling towards. Josh is misogynistic always questioning and blaming women. It’s just a weird show as a whole. Needs new hosts and restructure

Im sorry but josh is BORING!!! Can we please take him off or only put him in as commentary with Ana! We all come here for Ana! I am disappointed every time theres a new episode and its josh not ana 😮‍💨🥲👎 sorry josh

I find the topics so interesting but I can’t listen because Ana is a terrible host and laughs all the time for no reason. I only listen when Josh host.

I love hearing about current crimes and cases. Anna Garcia is THE BEST & her love for chihuahuas makes her even more lovable. Although one this there is a guest host on 9/1/23 episode and someone’s phone keeps buzzing and it’s making it very hard to listen to… anyway overall amazing podcast look forward to it every week.

I don’t need to listen to two bros debate whether revenge porn should be protected under free speech. It’s against the law and there’s no debate. Gross.

Another worthless podcast. They think they’re funny but are only immature amateurs.

Heard about this pod and decided to listen to a current episode. Ep 315 - Ana Garcia tried everything she could to race bait her guest, but the guest rose above and refused to play her game. Much respect to the guest for being quick to point out all valid arguments for bail consideration, not just the aspects that Garcia tried to twist to fit her own agenda. L pod and L for Garcia.

But I want to know WHERE ARE ANDREA ISOM AND CHRIS HANSEN????? And Joshua Ritter this is for you, the word is spelled “height” it is NOT pronounced “heighTH”! Stop making that egregious error as an educated man!

If you’re looking for interesting, thoughtful perspective and analysis this is NOT the show for you. Loads of obvious grandstanding and predictable assessments.

I’m sorry but Anna comes off like a person who understands the emotionality of crime and murder but not the psychology or laws.

Great discussions because they are direct, real, and some light discussions to help ease the depressing issues. Information is different from other podcasts which makes me wanting to keep coming back.

It is completely inexcusable to be cracking jokes, howling with laughter, and disrespecting the victims and families of murder. I am truly disgusted by how insensitive this podcast is. How violated you would feel if a family member or friend of yours had just been murdered and a complete stranger made a podcast episode mocking their life story, with no consideration as to the fact that these families are already going through the most painful time in their lives? And here you are with the audacity to use their tragedy and misfortune as sheer entertainment. Reconsider your story telling and take on the responsibility of a true crime podcast host to honor the victims and their loved ones; or do everyone a favor and stop podcasting.

The stories covered are compelling but I can’t take Ana’s constant laughing and corny jokes even if it’s about the accused in each case.

June 2 Ep was not good-Ana and guest seemed to not be aware mic was on-didn’t make sense, maybe wasn’t edited as usual. Confusing

Info is great, panel of experts are great love this podcast

I love both of the hosts. The episode about the pregnant Amish woman who filed charges against her abusive husband was one of the most moving podcasts I have ever listened to. I am still floored by her strength.

Enjoy the content but wish there were different hosts. Joshua is always interrupting the guests and Ana shrieks and sounds whiney.

On the Murdaugh episode with the pearl clutching about a swift verdict and the guest lawyer who bought Alex’s snot emotion. I had to stop listening. Lordt. Is money changing hands for these ridiculous opinions? That case wasn’t that complicated.

terrible discussion

The woman host screeching and laughing about victims of murder. Seriously so strange. None of the other people are acting like this is funny. I’m watching on tv. I probably won’t watch any more of this show. She’s hard to listen to. It’s about the Murdauch family and people who died. She’s laughing again. Big joke

You guys huh say huh a huh lot huh yeah huh it’s just huh hard to huh listen huh to…😂

First off our mental health system FAILED her. The state of Massachusetts failed her. That is who is responsible. She didn't just have postpartum depression , she had postpartum PSYCHOSIS. BIG difference. HUGE difference. Her kids where her WORLD, her EVERYTHING. In her psychosis state of mind she had NO IDEA what she had done. She should have NEVER been sent home, she should have been in a hospital type facility where she should have had 24 hour watch and care. Because our mental health system is a mess to say the least, she was sent home and was doing a intake care. This should have never happened.... again, OUR STATE, OUR MENTAL HEALTH SYSTEM needs to take RESPONSIBILITY. The "professionals" that evaluated her, that made the decision to allow her to go home should be held accountable. The "professionals " that put these guidelines in place need to be held accountable.

The guys that put out that podcast are anti USA. Can’t listen anymore.

Good podcast but have to stop listening because Ana is laughing hysterically at everything, she is so annoying… this stuff isn’t funny and she is cracking up constantly. It’s ok to laugh genuinely here and there when something is actually funny but she is busting a gut the whole podcast.

Soo boring

This episode is very difficult to listen to. The guest is not a very good presenter and the host continuously interrupts.