We feel like y’all are kindred spirits! We love the research and banter, and would absolutely love a collaboration at some point! Keep at it y’all!

Best podcast ever! Never ever stop telling the stories!

Love the banter these two have but I’ll be honest, one of these guys sounds like Jonah Hill. It’s not a bad thing it just makes me chuckle.

This show has been my latest listening addiction for the last month or so. Whenever I’m doing chores or playing video games I am listening to episodes. The banter is at times hilarious and the stories are always interesting.

Awesome paranormal podcast with humor. Amazing guys with great personalities. Always looking forward to Tuesdays now. They are only podcast I actually keep up with.

I’ve listened to you guys for a while now, but I’ve fully made the switch from Spotify to Apple Music… so I thought I’d leave another review! You guys have the most entertaining conversations, and what I love about this podcast specifically is that you have such an open mind…. You take everything seriously and with so much respect, which is so refreshing. I also love that this podcast is a safe space for so many, especially in a world where the media (including so many podcasts) is being taken over and turned into alt-right propaganda machines.

I’ve always been interested in the paranormal and things that can’t be explained and this podcast provides me with a great collection of diverse content to dive into. As well as the confidence to open up about my own paranormal experiences! By far my favorite podcast I’ve listened to yet. I would highly recommend BTB!

Been listening to this show for a couple months now and it’s quickly became one of my favorite podcasts to listen to. If you love all things spooky you’ll love this podcast!

I’ve been listening to this podcast for a couple of years now and it has become my absolute favorite! If you like spooky stuff and the paranormal, this is the pod for you!

I listen to you guys on Spotify but since I can’t leave a review there I thought I’d leave one here. I found this podcast while looking for more stories about stairs in the woods a little while back, I’ve never been into paranormal before but found this very interesting and I’ve been listening to you guys ever since. I went back and started listening to Charlie and Tyler from the beginning and all the inside jokes and just good camaraderie is so fun. I’m thinking of joining their Patreon and am also thinking of submitting my own listener submission, I’m looking forward to being part of your fun community. Charlie and Tyler if your reading this hope you guys have a great day and Aw man that’s great -Hadley

It’s informative and funny. Charlie and Tyler seem like my friends now. Lolol thank guys!

Awesome just relaxing talks about the bizarre and just funny hanging around them. It feels like hanging around with your friends on a regular day. 💜

Love listening to these two the crack me up!! Very informative and honest! I love there banter!! Im so glad I heard of them through let’s get haunted and scared to death

Tyler and Charlie do such an amazing job with every episode and the Instagram page is fun to follow as well!

Love these guys. They know how to have a good time and bring the spooky

You guys literally rock! One of my new faves, so binging has ensued! Thanks for the humor, intelligence, info, and spooks.

Love this podcast. Charlie and Tyler bring a really fun and lighthearted approach to the unsettling topics of the paranormal. For those of us who love spooky stuff, but also scare easily and get anxiety if they overindulge, this podcast is the perfect medium. I also love how much they interact with their listeners 💛

I just started listening a few days ago, but I love the vibes and the content is top tier! Gonna be slowly working my way through the library here, but I’m already recommending y’all to friends and family!

Love the pod deserves 5 stars. However, your intro music and transitions are way to loud and take me out of the great content!

I have been looking for new paranormal podcast and this is it! Episodes are a fun set up and I enjoy listening to your rationales for being believable, viable, etc! So many new stories I’ve never heard of! Keep it up! 😊

I have been listening to these for a while now. Love this podcast. Just another night in the sheshed. Art+scary stories=a fun night!

Keep doing what you’re doing, your different then most and keep me listening Thanks Darryl

Aww man…..so good. Double down

I love this podcast. They are hilarious and I love to hear them tell the stories and discuss. In short….ah man, that’s great.

I recently was on the hunt for a new good supernatural podcast to listen to and came across this one-and I was pleased to find that it was one that didn’t believe all stories 100 percent and actually was reasonable with the explanations behind an event. This is such a fun podcast and I totally recommend giving it a listen if you love anything supernatural. There’s some genuinely creepy content but plenty of times where I laugh at the jokes!

The endless stream of half-baked jokes and attempts to be witty rather than focusing on the subject matter are like a long row of speedbumps (Charlie is by far the worst with this, Tyler is much better). Or when they just ramble on and on about irrelevant garbage. It does nothing but interrupt the flow of the episode.

These guys are really immature and it shows in how they research things and how they talk about them. Its an ok show but sometimes I wish they took the topics they research more seriously, same with how they talk about things. The guardian angel show may be the catalyst that causes me to stop listening honestly. Not only due to the research but the childish jokes.

Thank you guys for bringing your hard research to us and feeding us the knowledge. Just started listening not long ago and it has been great. You guys are doing great at podcast. Many blessings your way.

im a nail artist and i have all my clients to listen to this podcast while i do their nails :D

Please see comment title.

A couple of years ago I was telling my kids about the melonheads legend. I went in search of a podcast that could give better information than I could. That’s how I found you guys. I’ve been loyal ever since. (Side note: I love that you’re from and reside in NE Ohio!) I listen to your show each week and I really enjoy it. You cover so many interesting and varied topics; each episode is entertaining and educational. Thanks for the laughs and the learning!

You guy’s should do an episode about the Bermuda Triangle

I love that this podcast covers all of the lesser known hauntings, cryptids and alien sightings among other spooky stuff you may not have heard of, not just the big ones.

I work solo most of the day and I am so glad I stubbled upon the is podcast! Thanks for keeping me on task with your interesting & spooky legends & lore!

I am so glad to have found this podcast. Every episode is unique and enjoyable. A great variety, and it never gets old. You guys have a great friendship that shows, and makes each episode flow very nicely Wicked awesome, thanks for all you guys do, and keep them coming!

This podcast is unique, interesting and entertaining! I always look forward to it every Tuesday 😄

In the future, y’all should take into consideration that when you are talking about stories from a different culture, to learn how to pronounce words before confidently saying them in your podcast. It can be offensive to the people that come from that culture. Even if the intention is pure, the impaction is can be hurtful.

I love the clear passion Tyler and Charlie have for this kind of stuff. Each episode feels genuine and it’s a lot of fun to listen to.

i listen to this so much my friends think i have an addiction to it. jokes aside i love this podcast so much. this podcast makes is a 10/10. i recommend it to almost everyone. thanks for making a binge worthy podcast. 😁

I’ve been looking for a podcast to listen to after catching up with my fav podcast! And omg FINALLY you guys are literally angel whispering sweet nothings in my ears😻😻 keep it up guys🤩

Get to the point

I love this show, you guys crack me up most of the time.

Love the show! Very entertaining and I love how they look at all sides of the possibilities.

I’m only up to the Edgar Allan Poe episode but I can’t understand how this podcast can tell me the same about of information in 30-40 minutes as a podcast that spends 3 hours on the same topic 🤔 Loving the podcast so far!!

I’ve been listening to this podcast everyday while working. I’m currently on the missing 411 & national forest disappearances. I will be submitting my story when I’m all caught up. 10/10 podcast!!!!

Always such a fun listen. Tyler and Charlie cover spooky topics with good banter, good details, and eerie narratives. Favorite podcast!

It’s so good! I definitely recommend

Was looking for a paranormal podcast when I found this gem! Absolutely entertaining and just so easy to listen to. Love it !

Started listening a month ago. It keeps me entertained at work. The guys are funny, especially when reading ads. Keep up the great work.

I love spooky podcast but I don’t like true crime shows… so this is the perfect blend between ghosts and creatures