Without a doubt; hands down the very best true crime podcast I’ve ever listened to! Extremely well written, researched and presented. I thought I knew every great TC pod out there and boy was I wrong! This podcast is simply the BEST! The hosts present each episode in an informative, sensitive and engaging format.

Murder in America is my new favorite podcast. The latest Dear Zachary episode hit me in the gut twice. A tragic story told with empathy, compassion and heartbreaking detail 💔

This is one of my favorites. It on my weekly list to listen to. Thank you for all of your hard work and the effort you put into your work.

Listening to Murder in America is now part of my Friday morning routine.

Would have given you 10 or more stars if I could!! Great job with all the stories yall tell! Thank you!

I like this podcast but man, relating something in every case back to yourselves makes me roll my eyes.

Thank you for this excellent podcast. Blessing to you for have the courage to name names even if a lot are already dead. I love the deeply researched and well presented job you do!!

I love this Podcast

I love this show!!!…. I listen to it every single day I’m at work… I’ve caught up to the newer shows this year….. you guys were made for this!!! Thank you so much ❤️🩷

I do enjoy this podcast, but once I hear Courtney repeatedly say “me and Colin”, that’s all I can think about. Please try to use proper English throughout the podcasts!

This is my all time favorite podcast! No 10 min beginning where they talk about themselves like other podcasts I’ve listened to. They jump write into the case! The sound effects and the times when Collin or Courtney will talk as the killer if they’d written something just emerges you right into it. The sympathy they have is amazing and the way they lay everything out makes it easy to follow along. This is my all time favorite podcast and I’ve listened to every episode! If I had the money I would subscribe to their patreon. This is the first show I put on when I have to clean my house.

when you interview people could you please say what they said in your guys voice, cause holy sht it was literally so hard trying to listen to the girl you guys interviewed talk in ep 3 tennessee bro

Although this is a good podcast that has been around for a while I still find it surprising that Courtney in particular tends to mispronounce names A LOT lol throughout some episodes she’ll pronounce the names correctly and then will completely butcher them. Don’t know if it’s a proofreading situation they need to fix or just pay attention more closely but definitely keep that in mind.

I really love the deep dive that you both dedicate to each story. Also the level of empathy that both of you show for each & every victim.💙 Love Courtney’s voice. BTW excellent episodes on 177 & 178! So sad! But very, very dedicated! Just wow, you both really went above & beyond going to get the son’s stuff!💜w2g! UPDATE: 179 is the perfect (chef’s kiss) follow up episode. Thank you two for this beautiful story. Often in true crime, the point gets lost. The point is to focus on the survivors of these senseless tragedies, and make sure they’re ok.

I have followed the Paranormal Files for many years over YouTube, and i have always loved Colin’s work & to see how much he has accomplished is amazing! Courtney has the best voice for this podcast i have listened since day one!!! 🖤🖤

Love the truth

Y’all’s podcast is on my top 3 🫡 you should really look into Mackenzie Cowell murder from Wenatchee WA. You might be interested in the story and I’m sure a lot of people here would find it a crazy story

I love their delivery on their podcast “chef’s kiss”

ive binged every show and subcategory of shows that collin does- every single one of them is such great quality. the most important part- the research, is done unbiasedly, thoroughly, and is always so organized in the presentation. y’all should look into ted kaczynski- the “unabomber”, found in a tiny little town in montana. i think its a state that hasnt been included in the state series 🙌🏻

I have followed Colin for many years on Tik Tok as I am into the paranormal. Then I had to start this podcast! The Conspiracy Files is great as well! I love that you both work together and really investigate each case. Keep up the great work!!

Poor grammar. “Courtney and I’s” is in every episode; it makes me nuts. Also, trying to relate every story to your personal life and or the paranormal is annoying.

Love this show! I’m aye on the road and hearing ram life stories has really helped time fly. What I tag about most though is how detailed they are with the stories. They really get into depth of the individuals involved and it really gives each story more of a draw!

But please learn proper grammar. I don’t know why so many podcasters don’t. It just drives me crazy.

I’ve been listening to this podcast for a while now, I found it when I was searching for new podcasts involving true crime. The concept is interesting and I love the format of covering a case by states. This show goes into very gory details which is why I listen to it in pieces. It’s hard to binge listen because of that. Earlier episodes also tended to focus on the paranormal aspects of the crime. I noticed once they said they hired writers, that element was taken out. I’m not caught up on all of the episodes currently I’m going through the middle of 2022 so I don’t know if they returned back to that format, but that is an aspect that is missed. I also know they mentioned they have other things going on in their lives so they hired writers, but to me, that takes away so much, especially with them. Hopefully they go back to writing their own episodes. The podcast is not bad at all. It’s a great listen, and I feel it could be great for those who like true crime. Just know that sometimes the details can be a bit much.

Do something from San Antonio, TX

Colin & Courtney does an amazing with this podcast. Well put together and it grabs my attention. A lot of work goes into creating this true crime story telling. Hearing cases I never hear before, really pulls me in. Keep doing what y’all are doing, cause I can’t stop listening.

One of my favorite podcasts 👏🏼🙌🏼

Great podcast out there with the best duo !!!

This is one of my top favorite podcasts.

This is the most outstanding True Crime podcast that I have ever listened to. Very well researched and presented. Y’all are my best friends in my head once a week. Stephany

I started listening to the old podcasts and all of the paranormal talk at the end of every single episode is annoying, but still very good podcasts with lots of effort put in to them. I would listen to dedicated paranormal podcasts if they ever put them out.

I really enjoy this podcast. It is interesting and well presented.

Great voices, great stories. A ton of details you won’t find from other TC pods.

My family and I love MIA. We have been listening to Courtney and Colin for over a year now. There is only 2 podcasts that we listen too. MIA is the best hands down.

This podcast is truly the best. I binge listened to every episode now I wait all week to listen to the newest! The facts and story telling is phenomenal!

Murder in America is the best true crime podcast in my opinion! The stories are so well researched and informative. I am hooked the minute they start telling the story. I look forward to a new episode every week! Love it! Great job, Courtney and Colin!

Fantastic storytelling! Your voices are a dream to listen to and the way you construct and deliver the cases is so compelling! Fantastic use of sound effects too! It definitely adds to the vibe of each case.

If you’re going to capitalize on the pain of others, at least be decent enough to accurately tell their stories. You’re storytellers, not historically accurate narraters. And your stories are so far off mark.

This entire podcast is just so captivating, thank you so much!! :)

I’ve been listening to you guys for years now. I look forward to everyday Friday while I sit in traffic to listen to Murder in America! It’s very articulate! Keep them coming!

This podcast brings the whole story to life. From how they talk, the sound effects and gosh i LOVEEE the body cam and phone call recordings they add, makes the timeline so easy to follow and you hear every detail of the case. I’m addicted.

Love Courtney and Colin love everything that they cover very informative. I even got my mom into this podcast. Definitely recommend a must hear podcast.

Interesting podcast. Very professional. No laughing or nonsense side stories. Thanks!

I enjoy Murder in America because they bring light to the victims stories and their families . They share the facts while also asking the questions we are thinking.

Best podcast I’ve heard in a while, love the way they tell a story so you can envision it. Courtney is amazing! Well done y’all! 👏🏻👏🏻

These two are incredibly talented storytellers who are clearly invested in the content they create. Their vocalics, attention to detail and sensitivity to the material are what set them apart. There is zero fat in this content—every word is deliberate. Love it. I tend to take life’s lemons and make stomach acid (#Facepalm), and this podcast is my escape from the world. Great stuff. 😊 Quick correction, however: trichotillomania falls into the category of obsessive-compulsive and related disorders in the diagnostic manual that mental health professionals use for diagnosis.

I’ve listened to several true crime podcasts, this is by far the best!!! Their voices are pleasant to listen to and they present stories in a way that keeps you interested.

My favorite podcast hands down

Been listening to True Crime forever and just found MIA recently. I know a lot of the stories already but happy to register since the way they tell the story is phenomenal. Top notch!

I like how they tell the story even if I have heard it on another podcast keep up the great work.✊🏾