Crime and Coffee Couple - True Crime Podcast

Love a cozy yet dark vibe? Join Allison and Mike, a witty, married duo with over 20 years of banter under their belts, for Crime and Coffee Couple—your weekly true crime fix. Kick back with a cup of coffee as their funny, relatable chitchat eases you into the dark corners of lesser-known cases, uncovered through Allison’s meticulous research. Fans love the refreshing blend of sarcasm and heart, balancing chilling stories with respect for the victims. It’s like sitting with friends who just happen to unravel mysteries—never sensational, always honoring the victims. Ready to sip and solve? Dive in!

Recent Episodes
  • The murder of Sonja Moen
    Apr 20, 2025 – 00:49:14
  • The murder of Suzanne Simpson
    Apr 13, 2025 – 00:52:19
  • MacDonald Family Murders AKA Fatal Vision Murders
    Apr 6, 2025 – 01:25:45
  • The death of Dakota James: The Smiley Face Killers?
    Mar 30, 2025 – 01:16:34
  • Uber Driver Shooting Rampage in Kalamazoo
    Mar 23, 2025 – 01:23:40
  • The Eastburn family murders
    Mar 16, 2025 – 01:11:33
  • The death of Olivia Gant
    Mar 9, 2025 – 00:54:54
  • The murder of Zander Lyda
    Mar 2, 2025 – 01:00:27
  • The murders of Elizabeth Collins and Lyric Cook
    Feb 23, 2025 – 00:55:00
  • The murder of Michelle Young
    Feb 16, 2025 – 01:10:15
  • The murder of Alyssa Burkett
    Feb 11, 2025 – 00:55:40
  • The murders of Libby German and Abby Williams (The Delphi Murders)
    Feb 2, 2025 – 01:01:42
  • The Nutty Putty Cave: The death of John Edward Jones
    Jan 26, 2025 – 00:58:19
  • A story of survival: Morgan Metzer
    Jan 19, 2025 – 00:49:46
  • The 'Affluezna Teen': Ethan Couch
    Jan 12, 2025 – 01:02:21
  • The death of Ashley Fallis
    Jan 5, 2025 – 01:05:40
  • The Lembcke family massacre
    Dec 29, 2024 – 00:47:04
  • The murder of Connie Dabate
    Dec 22, 2024 – 01:11:04
  • The murder of Michelle Martinko
    Dec 15, 2024 – 01:10:58
  • The murders of Ashley Pond and Miranda Gaddis
    Dec 8, 2024 – 01:03:25
  • The case of Gisèle Pelicot
    Dec 1, 2024 – 00:50:43
  • The murder of Leslie Reeves & the attempted murder of Chris Smith
    Nov 24, 2024 – 00:50:26
  • Becky Watts
    Nov 17, 2024 – 00:51:30
  • Serial Killer: Charlie Brandt
    Nov 10, 2024 – 01:02:20
  • The murder of Steve Clayton
    Nov 3, 2024 – 01:07:44
  • Paranormal Penitentiary : The Ohio State Reformatory
    Oct 27, 2024 – 00:58:07
  • The murder of Cherish Perrywinkle
    Oct 20, 2024 – 00:51:14
  • The murder of Greg Witman
    Oct 13, 2024 – 01:02:00
  • The murder of Jennifer Servo
    Oct 6, 2024 – 00:53:28
  • The murders of Heather Barnett & Elisa Claps
    Sep 29, 2024 – 01:02:22
  • The Brooke Skylar Richardson case
    Sep 22, 2024 – 01:05:42
  • 8 Passengers: The Twisted Story of Ruby Franke
    Sep 15, 2024 – 01:03:13
  • The murder of Samantha Josephson
    Sep 8, 2024 – 00:56:37
  • The death of Aubreigh Wyatt
    Sep 1, 2024 – 00:50:51
  • The death of Jaleayah Davis
    Aug 25, 2024 – 01:06:53
  • The murder of Mo Wilson
    Aug 18, 2024 – 00:51:01
  • Innocent James Joseph Richardson goes to prison
    Aug 11, 2024 – 00:50:03
  • The Soham Murders: Holly Wells & Jessica Chapman
    Aug 4, 2024 – 01:02:22
  • The murder of Bianca Devins
    Jul 28, 2024 – 01:05:42
  • Extra: Ask Us Anything Episode
    Jul 25, 2024 – 00:40:36
  • The murder of Joey Comunale
    Jul 21, 2024 – 01:03:53
  • The murder of Kacie Woody - early victim of online predators
    Jul 14, 2024 – 00:59:36
  • The mysterious death of Ellen Greenberg
    Jul 7, 2024 – 01:12:00
  • Survival story: Teri Jendusa-Nicolai
    Jun 30, 2024 – 00:51:18
  • The abduction of Jody Plauché
    Jun 23, 2024 – 00:57:45
  • Catherine Hoggle & the disappearance of Jacob & Sarah Hoggle
    Jun 16, 2024 – 00:50:40
  • The murders of Nancy Ludwig & Margarette Eby
    Jun 9, 2024 – 00:51:16
  • The mysterious death of Phoebe Handsjuk
    Jun 2, 2024 – 01:09:55
  • The disappearance of Etan Patz (Stranger danger)
    May 26, 2024 – 00:53:05
  • Unsolved: Disappearance of Suzy Lamplugh
    May 19, 2024 – 00:52:58
Recent Reviews
  • Kayy Knapp
    My favorite podcast!
    I came across the crime and coffee couple last year when I was pregnant & would listen everyday at work to get me through the day. I missed about 3 months of episodes after having my baby in January & now I’m back to catching up on my favorite podcast! I love Mike & Aly! Love the banter in the beginning always cracks me up before the story. I recommend this podcast to all of my friends!!
  • Overdrive app
    Too much cussing
    I really like the show , but come on. Cut out the F bombs. @@@ edited my stars from 3 to 5 !!! You guys cleaned up the language and now I love your podcast !! Thanks
  • ✝️lovedbygod✝️
    10/10
    Love this so much, so sad yet interesting
  • TonyB507
    Narrator
    Couldn’t get past the woman’s voice especially the moans at the end of sentences. Sorry.
  • Self7931
    Love the banter
    I've been bingeing for about 2 months now and immediately had to become an Apple Podcast subscriber so I could get the bonus episodes. I was never really a true crime podcast listener but somehow ran across this and took a chance. I love Mike and Aly’s chemistry and being the same age, so relatable. Fun clean show with episodes that are well researched and presented.
  • Harleycik24
    Listen to this podcast
    Awesome couple I love listening to you and love the stories you tell
  • Dougsdarlin
    Love lots of coffee, love my vodka too. Cudos to you and your sobriety!
    Thanks for a heartfelt storytelling podcast. Enjoy listening to you both!
  • sazar5585
    20/10
    Both have a heart of gold! it isn’t easy telling a victims story, and how so many can without empathy blows my mind. Not these two, you feel their pain for every victim, yet they know exactly when to insert a little light when things get dark. Thank you for such great material, and I really wish the best and most success to the both of you and your family! -Sarah
  • Cody Johnson 95
    10/10 true crime podcast
    I’ve been listening to true crime for about 6 years. I’ve heard all the mainstream well known podcasts, but I have to say Allison and Mike are BY FAR the best I’ve heard. Allison does an amazing job telling the stories of cases that aren’t as well known. The banter between Allison and Mike is very genuine. I appreciate how REAL these people are. 100% recommend!
  • BeeCuzThatsWhy
    🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩
    Honest banter, lots of fun… great storytelling!
  • Cinny420
    5/5 stars!
    I discovered this podcast on accident and I literally loved it from the beginning! I swear I listen to this podcast more than music. I love the banter, the way you tell the stories, and everything in between. I look forward to every Sunday!! Keep it up!!!
  • ssns112
    Nurse
    The story probably was good if I could tolerate woman’s voice! Terrible
  • Stellastarr222
    A+
    Great podcast! Mike’s opinions can be infuriating often times- it’s okay to sit and listen to your wife tell us the story and leave all your nonsense out of it- but as a whole I do enjoy the podcast.
  • beanandgigi14
    TIME WELL SPENT
    I’ve been bingeing for a few weeks, from the beginning. Finally subscribed for more episodes. I always feel weird saying a true crime podcast is great or some other glib descriptor, so I will say listening to CCC is time well spent. The subject matter is dark and both Allison and Mike show great tact and raw emotion in their narration. I follow them on YT, as well.
  • Sherrylynn812
    Love this couple
    I enjoy Alison and Mikes discussions! Their dry humor never fails to crack me up. I especially like when Alison ignores Mikes jabs as if she doesn’t hear them 🤣
  • B&nakan
    10/10 Recommend 🕺
    I’ve been binging for weeeks now- I love starting from the beginning of podcasts so i know their core and you two had me hooked. I’m currently listening to the story of Delimar Vera sooo i’m pretty far back, lol! You guys make me laugh out loud while working (i’m a house cleaner, i’m sure sometimes that’s concerning for my clients), always bring raw emotion to the table and never fail to bring the victims to light. Keep doing what you’re doing. PS. I’m 25 but i still take your guys advice to heart like you’re my parents, lowkey jealous of your kids!
  • KatPNC
    Funny
    Both great!
  • PeacheyGirl
    Cozy & Dark, as Promised
    Right up front, and in advance; 5 minutes in, I wanted to dislike this show for one reason and one reason only… Allison’s voice. BUT…. It’s just so good! Her candid, open, storytelling style is balanced out perfectly by her co-host and husband, Mike. They keep each other honest, while spotlighting the victims and details of each case they tell. I especially like that this couple actually notates the end of “chit chat” point in each podcast, giving the listener the option to skip it, if, for some reason Allison’s voice doesn’t grow on you like it has me!
  • C Montgomery KY
    My new favorite
    I’m always looking for new true crime podcasts and I’m so glad I found this one. Since I found it I’ve listened every day. I usually hate banter but I think both of you are so funny and play off of each other so well. I also love the authentic reactions to the cases. I feel like you guys truly care for the people you are talking about. The research and storytelling is great too. Keep up the great work!
  • Mariah Voig
    Love!
    I just found this podcast and love it.!
  • GBraum
    Fruity Suspenders
    My husband broke his suspenders last night, no joke. So no his apple shaped body is in trouble at work. It’s the only thing that keeps his pants up. Anyway, I love you guys and have binged myself right out of shows lol
  • helloambie86
    A must listen
    I look forward to this show every Sunday - it helps take away the Sunday scaries lol.- Allison really does her research and gives the full story- Mike used to cover stories but doesn’t as much anymore but when he did he also did a great job- definitely one of my favorite shows
  • CoffeeGirlBuzz
    Most relatable couple
    If you’re a fan of crime podcasts, you need to listen to this one! Alison and Mike’s chemistry is fantastic and they really delve into intriguing lesser known stories. Mike’s reactions are raw and genuine, making it even more fun to follow. 🍎🍌🍍
  • Packagedeal27
    🤩
    I ate so much pineapple while listening to your podcast, I had to put my suspenders on! Love you guys!
  • Gwenyth Boer
    Suspenders
    I love your guys show so much, you keep it light hearted and funny when you can, you’re extremely respectful to the people and victims you cover, you choose not common cases that need coverage. Thank you for being so good at what you do, and keep doing it! ♥️♥️
  • BurntMatchstick
    🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
    Oranges, Kiwi, Watermelon, Strawberries & Suspenders. What more could a girl want?
  • Kayegiddy
    Best podcast
    While suspenders have been in and out of fashion over the last century (alternating with belts in general preference), there has been a brief resurgence in interest. Love love this podcast 😊
  • kbish614
    Love this podcast
    🍌🍊🍍
  • Personwithopinion
    Not as well known cases
    Appreciate that you two aren't covering cases that have saturated true crime. Not that those cases don't deserve to be covered. More so that there are PLENTY others that also ought to get press. I don't like gory or sick crimes...I prefer baffling ones though. Solved or not. My favorite are mysterious disappearances. I do not mean no body homicides where everyone knows 'who dun it' but there just isn't enough forensic or circumstantial evidence to prosecute. So, I prefer Mike's cases as they tend to be less macabre. Both hosts bring alot of details and draw the audience into the cases. And neither of you are monotone and just reading off a piece of paper. Thank you for TELLING the stories, your banter back and forth, details, and inviting us to listen in. ETA: I've listened to a ton of episode episodes now. And was thinking of becoming a patron. However, Mike's incessant sophomoric sex talk or telling us how he's trying to get Alison to have sex with him is too cringy. It's not funny. It doesn't come off as playful banter between a loving couple. It comes off to me as perverted. And makes me question how he looks at and thinks about all adult females. It's not for public consumption and comes off as very pervy because it's allllll the time. If I were his son or daughter or other relative or friend or coworker, I would seriously be uncomfortable. Because as a listener I am uncomfortable. Which bums me out because I like the show, I like the banter between them except for this one area. I love how supportive he is of Alison. Of the way she contributes to the family in or outside of the home, her preferences for things or the way things are done, and how when she stumbles over a word and/or says one with almost a question in her voice...and he reassures her that she said it correctly or helps her when she doesn't. And I really really really like it when Mike takes the lead and tells us about cases because I like the kind of cases he picks. I don't want to skip the banter. I also don't want to hear about him constantly trying to have sex either.
  • nCarolina girl
    Great podcast!
    This is my new favorite podcast. I’ve binged entirely too many episodes without putting out and leaving a review, but wow, each episode has been great! Each episode is well researched and told with care and respect to the victims. Happy listening!!
  • Bgking8611
    Espresso machine
    I’ve had a Breville Barista Express for 5+ years and love it. I have lattes every day, and my husband likes pour over, Aeropress, or (using the Breville) Americanos. 💞
  • Boxcarvp45
    Glad I continued to listen.
    Hear me out!!!! I ran across this podcast by accident several months ago, at first I was hesitant to continue listening due to I thought Allison sounded like a stuck up Karen (don’t hate on me please continue to read) but I continued listening and her husband cracks me up with some of his comments and I learned that I was wrong she is not a stuck up Karen, she just has a unique sense of humor and delivery. I think Allison and Mike are the perfect couple due to the way they complement one another and I enjoy when Mike says something that throws Allison off such as “Phallus” (if you know you know). So if anyone is looking for a good True Crime Podcast that can be serious with humor thrown in then give this one a listen. Keep up the amazing podcast!!!
  • TLeeKyle
    5 STARS!!
    Great podcast! I’ve listened for a while. Look forward to it every week.
  • Swordfishtonight
    Great podcast
    Love the content and dynamic
  • RT Sarah
    Binging right through!
    My sister recommended your podcast to me and I love it! My husband and I are major coffee addicts as well. We’ve also been together since high school and have been married for 19 years! My sister knew I’d relate to you guys, we banter back and forth just like you:) Quickly becoming one of my favs!
  • Ericka . S
    Music to my ears!
    Perfect podcast to put on and clean like a crazy person !! Great duo and so relatable as a married person lol keep up the great work guys !
  • Sober Mommy of 3
    Needing more!
    Only good thing about my relapse was getting clean and having 10 months worth of episodes to binge! I’m all caught up now and love you guys still as much as I did a couple years ago! New deli to spread the word about this podcast, just need and want to get another hoodie to rock, one day!! Currently rebuilding my life and can afford to subscribe but that’s about it, I will get merch when I can! Thank you Allison and Mike for being so consistent!!
  • Jackiej13
    Banter
    Love the podcast and love how you can skip the banter. 🤣
  • Cathywren
    Just cant take the bickering
    Hate this couple’s interaction. He can’t say anything that she doesn’t pick at. Ugh.
  • Happy87678
    Best podcast I have found in a long time!!!!
    Loving their podcast so much and currently binging pretty much 24/7 since I have a newborn :)
  • MalloryT89
    Great to listen to
    I just found you guys only a few weeks ago and enjoy listening. Love the information you give. I love that you don’t sound so “scripted” and have the side conversations as well!
  • Imabamafan4one
    The best!
    I’m so glad I found this podcast. It’s my new favorite! Alison and Mike are absolutely awesome! I’m bingeing now! Thanks guys, you are great!😊
  • TNelly81
    Fun show!
    Love your show! Listening while on vacation and love the witty conversations you have. Made me smile laugh cry (along w Allison). You guys are so relatable! Thanks for the fun show! Teresa
  • Game Hil
    Hello!
    Started listening because I love the wife’s accent!!! I’m from Ky, so it’s very different from mine. lol Now, I listen because you’re respectful and to the point! You all do good research. Thank you for your show! Hilary
  • TeraOK
    I am picky
    I am a picky crime podcast listener, but I really like Crime and Coffee Couple! I listen at work, in the car, and in the mornings while I get ready to start my day. I am always looking for stories I haven’t heard before and this podcast delivers! Thanks for the great stories and P.S. I love coffee too ❤️☕️
  • Crystal Janel
    OBSESSED
    I’m obsessed with the podcast. I love how in depth you go in each case and the raw emotions you guys show when telling the cases. I can’t forget to mention the banter, it’s chef’s kiss. Ok love you, byyyee.
  • bbakee
    My favorite podcast
    Love y’all love the banter. Love the feeling and thought put into every single story . Keep it up guys
  • Laurensabina
    My favorite!
    I have been listening for a while and it’s my favorite podcast! Love the banter, love the vibe between you guys! Keep up the good work!
  • 85 degrees
    My walking buddy
    I enjoy the pre show banter but during the show Mike can be annoying On the episode about Bianca your banter about changing bedsheets resonated with me! Thanks for keeping me company during my evening walks!
  • sewcynful
    Great podcast!
    I just started listening to your podcast. I love your chemistry and your stories! I listened to your most recent podcast then decided to go back to the beginning. I’m really enjoying it!
Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork on this page are property of the podcast owner, and not endorsed by UP.audio.